Put-in-Bay Brewing Company

Brewery Appetizers

A mound of fries smothered in Cheddar and mozzarella cheese topped with crispy peppered bacon. Served with a zesty Ranch dressing
Six thick slices of mozzarella cheese breaded and deep fried to perfection served with marinara sauce
A half pound of chicken fries, served with your favorite dipping sauce
A basket of shoestring french fried potatoes
Sinfully delicious wedges of sweet potatoes served with a caramel sauce
Huge rings of onion battered and deep fried to a golden brown
A half pound of Walleye hand battered and flash fried. Served with our homemade tartar sauce
Ten fresh chicken wings tossed in your favorite sauce. Hot, Mild, BBQ, Hot BBQ, Hot Garlic Parmesan, Teriyaki. Served with Bleu Cheese or Ranch
Macaroni, jack cheeses, and bacon wrapped in a beer batter, fried to perfection and served with ranch for dipping.
A mound of Nacho chips smothered in cheddar and mozzarella cheese, topped with lettuce, tomato, onion, jalapenos and black olives. Served with salsa and sour cream.
Extras: Add grilled chicken or ground beef
Toasted pretzel bread topped with Basil Pesto, fresh sliced tomatoes and cream cheese.
Extras: Add grilled chicken or ground beef
Served golden & crispy with horseradish sauce for dipping.
Fresh mozzarella stuffed meatballs served with marinara sauce.

Homemade Soups

Made with a blend of aged cheddars and our own Bourbon Stout, garnished with shredded cheese, crispy bacon and toasted bread points.
Caramelized onion and Guinness broth, topped with croutons, provolone and swiss cheeses.

Brewery Salads

Fresh aritsan spring mix accompanied by dried cranberries, walnuts, cucumbers, bleu cheese and grilled chicken

Crisp romaine lettuce, Parmesan cheese and Caesar dressing, topped with our house made croutons
Fresh artisan spring mix topped with fresh tomatoes, onions, cucumbers and croutons
Thick sliced tomatoes and fresh mozzarella cheese lightly seasoned then drizzled with basil pesto and served with mixed greens
Fresh baby spinach with sliced avocado, perfectly grilled chicken, diced mangos & pineapple, finished with candied walnuts and goat cheese.

A smaller version of the Garden salad

Extras: Add to any salad:
Grilled chicken
Grilled steak
Seared Ahi Tuna

House-Made Ranch, Bleu Cheese, Italian, Caesar, Honey Mustard, Balsamic Vinaigrette, Mango Chardonnay Vinaigrette, Raspberry Vinaigrette

Brewery Hand-Pattied Burgers

All burgers come with fries. Substitute fresh veggie, cucumber & couscous salad, sweet potato fries, garlic mashed potatoes, onion rings, side salad.

Free Toppings:
Lettuce, Tomato, Raw Onion, Mayonnaise

Extra Toppings:
Grilled Onion, Grilled Mushroom, Avocado, Bacon, Fried Egg, Coleslaw, Bleu Cheese, American, Cheddar, Swiss, Pepper Jack
An 8oz burger topped with cheese, bacon, french fries, coleslaw and a fried egg
An 8oz burger smothered in barbecue sauce, topped with cheddar cheese, bacon and a giant onion ring
An 8oz burger with Cajun seasoning, jalapenos, pepper-jack cheese and fresh avocado. Served witha zesty ranch dressing
An 8oz burger topped with sauteed mushrooms, grilled onions and Swiss cheese
One pound of grilled hand-pattied ground beef, with your choice of cheese
A delicious blend of vegetables, rice and oats seasoned to perfection. Served with an artisan lettuce blend, tomato, onion and roasted red pepper pesto

Brewery Sandwiches

A lightly seasoned chicken breast served on a toasted egg bun. add cheese or bacon for a buck
A mound of peppered bacon, crisp lettuce and tomato, served with mayonnaise on toasted thick sliced bread
Slices of turkey, ham, bacon, and cheese with lettuce and tomato. Served with mayonnaise on thick sliced bread
Crispy battered Lake Erie Perch on a toasted egg bun. Served with our homemade tartar sauce

Brewery Entrees

A half pound of shrimp coated in a red hook beer batter. Served with fries and cocktail sauce
A generous portion of Lake Erie Perch served with fries, coleslaw and our homemade tartar sauce

Grilled to perfection and served with garlic mashed potatoes and vegetables.

Grilled mushrooms,
Grilled Onions
Crumbled Bleu cheese

Three tender pieces of chicken grilled and seasoned with basil pesto. Served with garlic mashed potatoes and vegetable
Three pieces of juicy grilled chicken breast smothered in our own homemade marsala & mushroom sauce. Served with garlic mashed potatoes and vegetable.
A generous portion of penne pasta served with marinara sauce and fresh meatballs. Served with garlic toast.
A bed of penne pasta with your choice of Cream Alfredo, Basil Pesto or Roasted Red Pepper Pesto sauce. Served with garlic toast.

Grilled chicken
Grilled steak

Famous Brewery Pizza

12" or 16"
Roasted Red Pepper pesto topped with grilled chicken, green peppers, onions and a cheddar mozzarella cheese blend
Basil pesto topped with tomatoes, black olives, banana peppers, onions and fresh mozzarella
Sweet Baby Rays sauce with grilled chicken, green peppers, onions and a cheddar mozzarella cheese blend
Garlic Aioli with cheddar and mozzarella cheese blend and bacon. Finished with fresh tomatoes and lettuce
Creamy Alfredo sauce topped with chicken, broccoli, tomato and mozzarella

The Island Stoner Pizza

This one quickly became an island tradition and has been perfected over the years. We start by baking two large egg-brushed pizza doughs topped with ranch dressing and cole slaw. Once baked, we add golded fried onion rings, ham, chicken sticks, macaroni and cheese wedges, mozzarella cheese sticks and french fries. Then we sprinkle with mozzarella and cheddar cheeses and bake again. Finally we combine the two pies creating the Island Stoner Pizza. Feeds about 6 people.

Think you can eat one by yourself in under one hour? Ask about the Stoner Pizza Challenge.

Create Your Own Pie!

Pepperoni - Sausage - Bacon - Ham - Chicken - Onions - Mushrooms - Black Olives - Green Peppers - Banana Peppers - Jalapenos - Tomatoes




Served with Brewery Fries
Extra: Additional toppings
Served with Brewery Fries
A combination of French Fries, Chicken Fries & Mozzarella Sticks.



Check with Your Server for Daily Specials



Homepage Our Beers Menu Location Employment Contact